Imagine being labeled the worst first-round quarterback pick in the last five seasons. That's exactly what happened to Kenny Pickett, the former Pittsburgh Steelers QB, according to ESPN’s Matt Miller. With the NFL Combine heating up and the draft just around the corner, the quarterback conversation is in full swing. But here's where it gets controversial: Pickett, drafted 20th overall in 2022, has been deemed the least successful first-round QB since 2021, despite the Steelers' desperate search for a successor to Ben Roethlisberger.
Miller’s analysis, based on pre-draft evaluations from scouts and executives, places Pickett at the bottom of the list, just below New York Giants QB Jaxson Dart and Atlanta Falcons QB Michael Penix Jr. Meanwhile, Chicago Bears QB Caleb Williams, the 2024 No. 1 overall pick, sits atop the rankings, with Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza—projected to go first overall this year—landing at No. 8. And this is the part most people miss: even though Pickett went 14-10 as a starter in Pittsburgh, much of that success was carried by the Steelers' stout defense, not his arm.
The Steelers' decision to draft Pickett from the University of Pittsburgh was a gamble in a weak quarterback class. While he showed glimpses of potential during his rookie season, consistency eluded him. An injury late in his second season opened the door for Mason Rudolph, who led the team to three straight wins and a playoff berth. Pickett was traded to the Philadelphia Eagles the following offseason, as the Steelers pivoted to Russell Wilson and later Justin Fields. Now on his fifth team in just four seasons, Pickett’s first-round status feels like a distant memory.
But let’s pause for a moment—was Pickett really the worst option? Here’s a bold take: Malik Willis, once considered a top quarterback prospect, has barely seen the field since being drafted, yet he’s expected to cash in this offseason after showing promise as a backup in Green Bay. Would he have fared better in Pittsburgh? It’s hard to say. Meanwhile, San Francisco 49ers QB Brock Purdy, Mr. Irrelevant in 2021, is the only quarterback from that draft class to emerge as a consistent starter. This raises a thought-provoking question: In a weak quarterback class, is any first-round pick truly a safe bet?
The Steelers' struggle to find their franchise quarterback continues, and Pickett’s story serves as a cautionary tale. While his selection didn’t pan out, it’s worth asking: Could anyone have succeeded in that spot? Let’s spark some debate—do you think Pickett was unfairly labeled, or was this the right call? Share your thoughts in the comments!
