One costly error can haunt a player for years, but for Sal Stewart, it might just be the catalyst that propels him into Major League stardom. That’s right—one bad throw could define a career, but here’s where it gets controversial: can a single mistake truly overshadow a player’s potential? Let’s dive into Stewart’s journey and find out.
In Goodyear, Arizona, Stewart spent his offseason replaying that fateful moment from Game 2 of the National League Wild Card Series against the Dodgers. Playing first base for the Reds, he botched a throw to pitcher Nick Martinez in the sixth inning, leading to a four-run rally and an 8-4 loss that sealed Cincinnati’s fate in a two-game sweep. But here’s the part most people miss: Stewart wasn’t just thrown into the fire—he was promoted to the big leagues on September 1st after only two games at first base in Triple-A. Talk about learning on the job.
‘It haunted me the whole offseason,’ Stewart admitted. ‘I’m excited to get back out there and prove I can be that defender. Everyone always doubts my defensive skills, but my Minor League stats tell a different story. I’m ready to show what I can do.’
Manager Terry Francona acknowledged the challenge Stewart faced: ‘That was so unfair to him. He handled himself fine, and he’ll be OK.’ General manager Brad Meador added, ‘Stewart shot through the system so fast, we couldn’t get him the first base reps he needed.’
Now, as the Reds’ top prospect and MLB Pipeline’s No. 22 overall, the 22-year-old is poised to build on his September call-up, where he slashed .255/.293/.545 with five home runs, eight RBIs, and 11 runs scored. To solidify his spot, Stewart will likely need to win the first base job, especially with Spencer Steer shifting to left field and the infield.
‘I’m just grateful for the opportunity,’ Stewart said. ‘Tito’s the Hall of Fame manager—I trust his plan. My job is to go out there and give it my all.’
Off the field, Stewart made headlines by shedding 26 pounds before Christmas, dropping from his listed 224 pounds to a leaner, more athletic frame. Initially worried about losing power, he’s now confident his swing remains potent. ‘As long as my swing stays compact, the power won’t go anywhere,’ he assured.
Francona has taken notice, praising Stewart’s improved athleticism. ‘When you watch him move, you can see the work he’s put in,’ Francona said. Assistant bench coach Mike Napoli, who works with first basemen, has echoed this sentiment.
The Reds’ signing of Eugenio Suárez adds another layer to Stewart’s path. Suárez will split time between designated hitter, first base, and third base—positions Stewart also plays. If Suárez is at DH and Steer is in left field, first base becomes Stewart’s to claim. This move could ease the pressure on Stewart to be the team’s primary power hitter.
But here’s where it gets controversial: Francona posed a thought-provoking question: ‘What does Sal do for Suárez? Sal’s a pretty good hitter. He’s young, still developing defensively. How does he fit? How does he help you win?’
Stewart remains confident. ‘I know what I bring is up to par at the big league level,’ he said. ‘As long as I maintain the mindset that I belong here, I’m super excited for the season.’
So, what do you think? Can Stewart overcome that one costly error and become a defensive powerhouse? Or will the pressure of the big leagues prove too much? Let us know in the comments—this is one debate you won’t want to miss!
