Who will dominate the NCAA postseason? The swimming world is buzzing with predictions, and one name keeps rising to the top.
In our latest SwimSwam Pulse poll, powered by A3 Performance, we asked readers to predict which midseason addition to NCAA teams would make the biggest splash in February and March. The results are in, and a clear frontrunner has emerged: Alex Shackell, the highly touted Indiana Hoosier, garnered a whopping 54.4% of the votes. But is she truly the most impactful newcomer? Let’s dive into the details and explore why Shackell is generating so much excitement—and whether other swimmers might surprise us.
But here's where it gets controversial... While Shackell’s credentials are undeniably impressive, other swimmers like Anastasia Gorbenko (16.2% of votes) and Mizuki Hirai (12.4%) are also poised to make waves. Could the poll results be overlooking their potential? We’ll break down their strengths and why they might just challenge Shackell’s dominance.
The Contenders and Their Credentials
This season’s midseason additions include some of the most talented swimmers in the world. Shackell, the top-ranked domestic recruit in the girls’ high school class of 2025, brings NCAA title potential in the 200 fly. Her personal best of 1:50.15 would have secured her a third-place finish at the 2025 NCAAs, and with the top two finishers graduated, she’s a strong favorite. But Shackell isn’t just a one-event wonder—her versatility in the 100 fly, 50 free, and relays makes her a game-changer for Indiana. Her debut against Michigan on January 9th showcased her prowess, with wins and impressive splits that left fans in awe.
And this is the part most people miss... While Shackell’s individual prowess is undeniable, her relay contributions could be the X-factor that propels Indiana to new heights. With four relay medals from the 2024 Short Course World Championships, she’s a proven team player. But are we underestimating the relay impact of swimmers like Hirai, whose SCM World Junior Records in the 50 back and 100 fly make her a medley relay powerhouse for Tennessee?
The Dark Horses
Anastasia Gorbenko, Louisville’s versatile star, is a force to be reckoned with. The 2021 short course world champion in the 50 breast and 100 IM, Gorbenko’s ability to excel in multiple events could give Louisville a significant edge. Her immediate impact was evident in her debut against Mizzou, where she clocked a 58.45 in the 100 breast and delivered lightning-fast free splits on relays. Could her versatility make her the most valuable addition, despite Shackell’s individual dominance?
Ksawery Masiuk, joining Texas after a delayed commitment, brings elite backstroking skills and strong sprint free and fly abilities. His performance at the European SC Championships, including a 49.52 in the 100 fly and a 20.62 50 free relay split, suggests he’ll be a major points scorer in multiple events. But will he be able to challenge for individual titles, or will his impact be primarily in relays?
The Underdogs
Tessa Giele, heading to Alabama, is one of the world’s best SC sprint butterfly swimmers, with a 54.66 in the 100 fly that ranks #5 all-time. Koen de Groot, an intriguing breaststroke talent, joins Florida, while Evan Bailey, a bronze medalist in the 200 free at SC Euros, teams up with Masiuk at Texas. While they may not be frontrunners, their potential to surprise cannot be overlooked.
The Big Question
As we look ahead to the postseason, the debate rages on: Is Shackell truly the most impactful addition, or will Gorbenko, Hirai, or Masiuk prove the poll wrong? And what about the underdogs—could one of them emerge as a dark horse contender?
We want to hear from you! Do you agree with the poll results, or do you think another swimmer will steal the spotlight? Share your thoughts in the comments below and let’s keep the conversation going. Who do you think will score the most NCAA points? Cast your vote in our new A3 Performance Poll and be part of the discussion!
About A3 Performance
A3 Performance is an independently-owned, performance swimwear company fueled by a passion for swimming and athletic excellence. We’re dedicated to helping swimmers of all ages and levels reach their full potential, from beginners to Olympians. With innovative products and a commitment to the sport, A3 Performance inspires swimmers to be their very best—an A3 Performer. The A3 Performance Poll is brought to you in partnership with SwimSwam, your go-to source for all things swimming.
